February 27, 2013

Questions — and answers — about “legitimate business reasons”

Posted in At-will Employment, Discrimination, Legitimate business reason, Legitimate Business Reason for Termination or other Adverse Action, Wrongful Termination tagged , , , , , at 1:46 pm by Tom Jacobson

Questions, I’ve got some questions
I want to know you
But what if  I could ask you only one thing
Only this one time, what would you tell me?

— Jack Johnson, Questions (2006)

In the song Questions, Jack Johnson ponders the myriad of questions swirling around in his head about a new relationship. What are your intentions, suggestions and impressions? Will you try?

When we’re thinking about something new and exciting, our main curiosity is this: where will this lead? Our hope is that it will lead to a good place.

When bad things happen, we also have questions.  Most often the question is, “Why?”

So it is when an employer must discipline or discharge an employee. When that happens, the question swirling around in the employee’s head is often, “Why?” If the employer cannot offer legitimate business reasons for its actions, not only is the employee left scratching his or her head and wondering why, but the employer may struggle to defend the ensuing lawsuit when the employee claims the answer to “Why?” is discrimination or some other legal wrong.

The importance of having legitimate business reasons for an employment decision was recently reiterated in the case of Wood v. SatCom Marketing, LLC. In this case, Jenna Wood sued her former employer, SatCom, alleging violations of the Minnesota Whistleblower Act, Minnesota Human Rights Act, common law of wrongful termination, and the Fair Labor Standards Act. The case made its way to the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit where the court rejected Woods’ claims after noting that while there was some evidence to support Wood’s claim, SatCom presented evidence of its legitimate business reasons for suspending and then dismissing Wood.

Specifically, the Court credited SatCom’s evidence that Wood severely neglected a data entry assignment, was late for work and failed to submit a required schedule. This, the Court said, supported the company’s decision to suspend Wood. The Court also noted that following her suspension, Wood disregarded a company directive by failing to return to work with a signed copy of an action plan and then twice violated the plan itself. Therefore, the Court held, SatCom had legitimate non-discriminatory reasons for its decision to discharge Wood. Further, the Court ruled that Wood did not present any evidence that SatCom’s stated reasons were a pretext for any unlawful discrimination. Thus, the Court affirmed the trial court’s decision to dismiss the case.

What you need to know: When employees challenge the adverse actions taken against them, employers have a much easier time defending the claims when they can present evidence of the legitimate non-discriminatory business reasons for their actions. Moreover, when those reasons are made clear to an employee before the adverse action, the employee may be less likely to challenge the employer’s decision because he or she will already have the answer to the question: s/he will already know why. 

For more information about this article, please contact me at alexandriamnlaw.com or  taj@alexandriamnlaw.com.

The comments posted in this blog are for general informational purposes only. They are not to be considered as legal advice, and they do not establish an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice regarding your specific situation, please consult your attorney.

Copyright 2013 Swenson Lervick Syverson Trosvig Jacobson Schultz, PA

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: